Top Rated Disc Golf Putters: Honest Reviews
Quick Comparison
| Product | Speed↑ | Glide↑ | Turn↑ | Fade↑ | Best For | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Kastaplast Reko | 3 | 3 | 0 | 1 | Straight flight with minimal fade - 4.9 star average | Check Price |
 MVP Atom | 3 | 3 | 0 | 1 | Consistent feel and straight flight paths | Check Price |
 Gateway Wizard | 2 | 3 | 0 | 2 | Players who want plastic variety and a classic feel | Check Price |
 Innova Aviar | 2 | 3 | 0 | 1 | All-around reliability and straight flight | Check Price |
 Discmania P2 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 1 | Overstable putting in windy conditions | Check Price |
Kastaplast Reko
Straight flight with minimal fade - 4.9 star average
Check Price on Amazon
Gateway Wizard
Players who want plastic variety and a classic feel
Check Price on Amazon
What do real disc golfers think about the putters they throw? We've analyzed thousands of player reviews to find the highest-rated putters in disc golf. These aren't marketing claims - they're honest assessments from players who have put these discs through real-world testing.
Our Review Methodology
We looked at ratings from multiple sources: Infinite Discs, Amazon reviews, and disc golf forums. We focused on putters with significant review volume (100+ reviews) to ensure statistical reliability. The ratings below represent community consensus, not manufacturer claims.
Top Rated Putters
Kastaplast Reko - 4.9/5
Kastaplast Reko
Straight flight with minimal fade - 4.9 star average
Straight flight with minimal fade - 4.9 star average.
What Reviewers Love:
- Premium K1 and K3 plastics feel amazing
- Incredibly straight flight for point-and-shoot putting
- Holds up well to tree hits
MVP Atom - 4.8/5
MVP Atom
Consistent feel and straight flight paths
Dead straight with unique overmold feel - 4.8 star average.
What Reviewers Love:
- Overmold technology provides consistent feel disc-to-disc
- Dead-straight flight regardless of power
- Works equally well for putting and throwing
Gateway Wizard - 4.7/5
Gateway Wizard
Players who want plastic variety and a classic feel
Classic beaded putter with incredible plastic variety.
What Reviewers Love:
- Incredible variety of plastic options
- Comfortable beaded rim
- Slightly overstable fade fights wind
Innova Aviar - 4.6/5
Innova Aviar
All-around reliability and straight flight
The standard by which all putters are measured.
What Reviewers Love:
- Proven at every level from beginner to World Champion
- Available everywhere at affordable prices
- Consistent production quality
Discmania P2 - 4.7/5
Discmania P2
Overstable putting in windy conditions
Overstable putting putter for windy conditions.
What Reviewers Love:
- Rock solid in windy conditions
- Great for forehand approaches
- Reliable overstable fade
Common Review Themes
Feel Matters Most
Across all putter reviews, "feel in the hand" is the most-mentioned factor. Players prioritize how the disc sits in their grip over flight characteristics. This is why trying before buying is so important for putters.
Consistency is Key
High-rated putters share one trait: consistency. Players want the same flight from disc to disc. This is where premium manufacturers like Kastaplast and MVP excel - their quality control produces nearly identical discs.
Plastic Preferences Vary
Reviews show strong opinions about plastic softness. Some players swear by soft plastics for chain grabbing, while others prefer firm plastics for consistent release. Neither is wrong - it's personal preference.
How to Use These Reviews
High ratings don't guarantee the disc is right for you. Use reviews to narrow your options, then try discs before committing. Most disc golf shops allow field testing, and many local clubs have disc swap events.
Final Thoughts
The highest-rated putters earned their ratings through thousands of real-world tests by real players. Trust the community - but also trust your own hands. The best putter is the one that feels right to YOU. For in-depth reviews of each putter, see our top 10 putters reviewed guide.
Affiliate Disclosure
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Pine Tree Disc earns from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Learn more