Compare Disc Golf Discs

Pick two or more discs and see exactly how they differ - flight, feel, distance, and price, side by side.

Build your comparison2 of 4 discs · ready

Lone Star DiscPenny PutterPutt & Approach3/4/0/2

Prodigy DiscP Model SPutt & Approach3/5/0/2

Penny Putter vs P Model S

How Penny Putter and P Model S compare on flight numbers, feel, distance, and price.

Key differences

GlidePenny Putter 4 vs P Model S 5Diameter21 vs 21.3 cm (-0.3)Rim width1.1 vs 1 cm (+0.1)PlasticsPenny Putter 12 vs P Model S 10PriceP Model S is cheaper ($5.00 less)

Flight Paths

Overhead view · right-hand backhand

Tap to show / hide

Tap a disc to show or hide its path. Estimated from flight numbers.

Lone Star DiscPenny PutterPutt & Approach

Prodigy DiscP Model SPutt & Approach

Flight Numberslonger bar = more of that trait

SpeedRim & velocity

Penny Putter

P Model S

GlideStays aloft

Penny Putter

P Model S

TurnHigh-speed bend

Penny Putter

P Model S

FadeLow-speed hook

Penny Putter

P Model S

Specifications

Differences only

Spec

Lone Star Disc

Penny Putter

Prodigy Disc

P Model S

Flight rating≠

3/4/0/2

3/5/0/2

Stability

Overstable (+2)

Beginner score≠

52/100

54/100

Est. carry≠

242 ft

250 ft

Type

Putt & Approach

Recommended skill

Everyone

Diameter≠

21 cm

21.3 cm

Height

1.9 cm

Rim depth≠

1.5 cm

1.2 cm

Rim width≠

1.1 cm

1 cm

Max weight≠

174.3 g

176 g

Bead≠

Beadless

Beaded

Plastics≠

12view on disc page →

10view on disc page →

PDGA Approved≠

Yes

On Amazon

Not on Amazon

Price from≠

$17.99

$12.99

The Verdict

Penny Putter or P Model S?

Main difference: glide (Penny Putter 4 vs P Model S 5). The P Model S floats and carries farther; the Penny Putter holds its line better in wind.

Penny Putter: OverstableP Model S: Overstable

Where to buy

Penny Putter

$17.99

Buy atAffiliate link

Best price

P Model S

$12.99

Buy atAffiliate link

We earn a commission on purchases through these links, at no cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

FAQ

Is the Penny Putter or P Model S more overstable?

They are equally stable (both +2) - turn 0/0, fade 2/2.

Should a beginner pick the Penny Putter or P Model S?

A beginner is better off with the P Model S (beginner score 54/100 vs 52/100) - lower speed and more turn make it easier to control.

What is the difference between the Penny Putter and P Model S?

Main difference: glide (Penny Putter 4 vs P Model S 5). The P Model S floats and carries farther; the Penny Putter holds its line better in wind.

Which is cheaper, the Penny Putter or P Model S?

The P Model S is cheaper, starting around $12.99 vs $17.99.

View each disc