Compare Disc Golf Discs

Pick two or more discs and see exactly how they differ - flight, feel, distance, and price, side by side.

Build your comparison2 of 4 discs · ready
Lone Star DiscHarpoonMidrange4/3/0/2
DiscmaniaP4Midrange4/3/0/2

Harpoon vs P4

These 2 midranges share the same flight numbers - the deciding factors are plastic selection, price, and availability.

Key differences

Diameter21.5 vs 21.3 cm (+0.2)Height1.7 vs 2 cm (-0.3)PlasticsHarpoon 9 vs P4 0PriceHarpoon is cheaper ($6.00 less)

Flight Paths

Overhead view · right-hand backhand

0100200300400500Distance (ft)Fade / Turn
Tap to show / hide

Tap a disc to show or hide its path. Picks that share flight numbers are nudged apart so each one is visible. Estimated from flight numbers.

Lone Star DiscHarpoonMidrange
DiscmaniaP4Midrange
Flight Numbers
SpeedRim & velocity
Harpoon
4
P4
4
GlideStays aloft
Harpoon
3
P4
3
TurnHigh-speed bend
Harpoon
0
P4
0
FadeLow-speed hook
Harpoon
2
P4
2
Specifications
Spec
Lone Star Disc
Harpoon
Discmania
P4
Flight rating
4/3/0/2
4/3/0/2
Stability
Overstable (+2)
Overstable (+2)
Beginner score
47/100
47/100
Est. carry
254 ft
254 ft
Type
Midrange
Midrange
Recommended skill
Everyone
Not listed
Diameter
21.5 cm
21.3 cm
Height
1.7 cm
2 cm
Rim depth
1.2 cm
1.4 cm
Rim width
1.2 cm
1.1 cm
Max weight
178 g
177 g
Bead
Beadless
Beadless
PDGA Approved
No
No
On Amazon
Not on Amazon
Not on Amazon
Price from
$17.99
$23.99
The Verdict

Harpoon or P4?

The Harpoon and P4 fly almost identically (4/3/0/2). Go with the Harpoon - it offers more plastic and weight options (9 blends), is easier to find, and costs less.

Harpoon: OverstableP4: Overstable
Where to buy
Best price
Harpoon
$17.99
Buy atAffiliate link
P4
$23.99
Buy atAffiliate link

We earn a commission on purchases through these links, at no cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

FAQ

Is the Harpoon or P4 more overstable?

They are equally stable (both +2) - turn 0/0, fade 2/2.

Should a beginner pick the Harpoon or P4?

Both rate the same for beginners (47/100). Pick by feel and price.

What is the difference between the Harpoon and P4?

The Harpoon and P4 fly almost identically (4/3/0/2). Go with the Harpoon - it offers more plastic and weight options (9 blends), is easier to find, and costs less.

Which is cheaper, the Harpoon or P4?

The Harpoon is cheaper, starting around $17.99 vs $23.99.

View each disc

Lone Star Disc Harpoon vs Discmania P4: Flight Numbers Compared