Compare Disc Golf Discs

Pick two or more discs and see exactly how they differ - flight, feel, distance, and price, side by side.

Build your comparison2 of 4 discs · ready

InnovaCommanderMidrange5/3/0/4

DiscmaniaMD5Midrange5/3/0/4

Commander vs MD5

These 2 midranges share the same flight numbers - the deciding factors are plastic selection, price, and availability.

Key differences

Diameter21.8 vs 21.2 cm (+0.6)Height2.2 vs 2 cm (+0.2)Rim width1.4 vs 1.5 cm (-0.1)

Flight Paths

Overhead view · right-hand backhand

Tap to show / hide

Tap a disc to show or hide its path. Picks that share flight numbers are nudged apart so each one is visible. Estimated from flight numbers.

InnovaCommanderMidrangeOut of Production

DiscmaniaMD5Midrange

Flight Numberslonger bar = more of that trait

SpeedRim & velocity

Commander

MD5

GlideStays aloft

Commander

MD5

TurnHigh-speed bend

Commander

MD5

FadeLow-speed hook

Commander

MD5

Specifications

Differences only

Spec

Innova

Commander

Discmania

MD5

Flight rating

5/3/0/4

Stability

Very overstable (+4)

Beginner score

36/100

Est. carry

274 ft

Type

Midrange

Recommended skill

Intermediate, Advanced

Diameter≠

21.8 cm

21.2 cm

Height≠

2.2 cm

2 cm

Rim depth≠

1.2 cm

1.3 cm

Rim width≠

1.4 cm

1.5 cm

Max weight≠

180.9 g

176 g

Bead

Beadless

Plastics

PDGA Approved≠

Yes

On Amazon

Not on Amazon

Production status≠

Out of production

In production

Price from≠

Not listed

$21.99

The Verdict

Commander or MD5?

The Commander and MD5 fly almost identically (5/3/0/4). Choose the Commander for far more plastic and weight options (0 blends) and easier availability; choose the MD5 to spend less.

Commander: Very overstableMD5: Very overstable

Where to buy

Commander

See retailer

Out of production

Buy atAffiliate link

MD5

$21.99

Buy atAffiliate link

We earn a commission on purchases through these links, at no cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

FAQ

Is the Commander or MD5 more overstable?

They are equally stable (both +4) - turn 0/0, fade 4/4.

Should a beginner pick the Commander or MD5?

Both rate the same for beginners (36/100). Pick by feel and price.

What is the difference between the Commander and MD5?

The Commander and MD5 fly almost identically (5/3/0/4). Choose the Commander for far more plastic and weight options (0 blends) and easier availability; choose the MD5 to spend less.

View each disc